Housing Crisis looms over Columbus’ self-proclaimed reputation as the “Silicon Heartland”

 

Ohio has made its reputation on being an approachable, affordable Midwestern state. With a variety of regional focuses including agriculture, manufacturing and entrepreneurship, Ohio’s diversity of profession is what makes its appeal. Columbus in particular has established itself as the fastest-growing city in the state, in part due to employment opportunities and affordability. This, coupled with announcements of arrival from tech companies like Intel and Google, has increased the city’s rapid development. However, Columbus has a long history of underdevelopment, resulting in a shortage of infrastructure and housing. At the cusp of a major population influx, Columbus finds itself at the crossroads of economic prosperity and systemic upheaval. 

 

Phoebe Helms

Patricia B. Miller Special Projects Reporter

Whether or not future renters or homebuyers are aware, central Ohio’s tech boom may prove to be a double-edged sword, exacerbating the region’s growing housing crisis. 

In January 2022, Intel — one of the largest semiconductor manufacturers in the world — announced plans to invest over $20 billion into constructing two chip factories in Licking County, Ohio. Currently, Intel’s primary locations are in Arizona, California, New Mexico and Oregon. 

Economic prosperity in regions where Intel is located has grown tenfold, and its contribution to the U.S.’s GDP was $25.9 billion in 2019 alone. Intel’s announcement marked the single largest private sector investment in the history of Ohio, and the project is expected to add approximately $2.8 billion to Ohio’s economic growth, according to the company. 

Intel is expected to bring in about 3,000 new hires for the company and over 7,000 construction jobs. Originally planned to be completed in 2025, Intel recently announced a delay of the project into late 2026 due to a slow chip market.

Other tech hubs like Google, Meta and Amazon have also established relatively new roots in the Columbus region. Jobs and investment from all of these tech businesses will expand Columbus’s population considerably.

Construction efforts in Licking County have increased road closures and are likely to boost traffic in the region.

Credit: Molly Goheen | Managing Editor for Digital Content
According to a 2023 study by the Mid-Ohio Regional Planning Commission, the 15 counties comprising central Ohio are expected to reach over 3 million people by 2050. 

All these new residents need places to live in what is already considered one of the nation’s fastest-growing housing markets, worsening fears of gentrification and displacement among minority communities in central Ohio.

According to Carlie Boos, the executive director at the Affordable Housing Alliance of Central Ohio, Columbus’ rapid development poses a risk to everyone unless the city takes drastic steps for development. 

“The underlying truth is that we are growing rapidly through tech, through industry, through innovation, through education, through all of these different sectors and as a combined wave. We’re just not keeping up on housing,” Boos said. “I don’t think that there’s any neighborhood that gets out safe. I think that every single one of our communities is in a really significant risk right now.”

Another significant factor of Columbus’ housing crisis was the city “never quite recover[ing]” from the 2008 housing crash, Jason Reece, an associate professor of city and regional planning at the Knowlton School of Architecture and an expert on the intersection of social equality and regional planning, said.

“I don’t think that there’s any neighborhood that gets out safe. I think that every single one of our communities is in a really significant risk right now.

                           — Carlie Boos, executive director at the Affordable Housing Alliance of Central Ohio

“While there’s certainly more construction in the last five years or so, [we] not only lost a lot of housing units from the foreclosure crisis but really construction has never returned to work or are caught up since that point,” Reece said. “And so that’s kind of leading us — before even these entities come in — we have [a] 50,000-plus shortage of affordable rental units, just here in Franklin County, before Intel gets here.”

Intel executives did not respond to a request for comment about their new plants’ impact, but Columbus development officials say it’s not Intel’s fault. 

Kenny McDonald, the president and CEO of the Columbus Partnership team, a nonprofit conglomerate of Columbus businesses and CEOs, said supply and demand are at the core of the issue and not to blame the arriving companies.

“Intel and Google and others that have really just arrived, and at this point, have very modest job growth [and] are absolutely not the root of our housing affordability issues. It really is a supply and demand issue more than anything,” McDonald said. “I will say that the announcement of these major projects create an anticipation that there’s going to be additional growth. And that we want to make sure that we’re constantly communicating what that growth is, where those workers are going to need to live.”

Considerable economic pledges have also been made, with Gov. Mike DeWine promising a $90 million investment into infrastructure and development surrounding the Intel plants. Intel itself has also pledged $100 million to Ohio’s educational institutions.

On the surface, it seems that Central Ohio should be thriving with its newfound influx of jobs, investment and money. 

“Intel and Google and others that have really just arrived, and at this point, have very modest job growth [and] are absolutely not the root of our housing affordability issues. It really is a supply and demand issue more than anything.”

                           — Kenny McDonald, president and CEO of the Columbus Partnership team

New Albany development officials drive into Intel’s construction site.

Credit: Caleb Blake | Photo Editor
However, this much growth in a limited amount of time reveals the darker reality of development. 

Stephanie Moulton, a professor with expertise in housing policy and finance at Ohio State’s John Glenn College of Public Affairs, said the arrival of tech companies like Intel will contribute to economic productivity in the region. Still, it will also undoubtedly bring about problems with housing supply and community planning due to a historical lack of housing within the region. 

“Intel might bring in higher-wage workers, which is fabulous. You might worry about the populations that are here, that are not able to purchase homes, or that are in rental housing, where the house prices tend to go up, when you have a limited housing supply in an area, and you have an increase in demand, you’re gonna see prices go up, obviously,” Moulton said. “And so one of the worries is that individuals in Columbus or in our surrounding communities like Licking County where Intel is going to be created, that the average wages of those individuals are going to be much lower than the wages of Intel workers, and the house price appreciation that’s going to happen.”

Columbus housing by the numbers

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Competition and prices will likely increase on rental properties in Columbus.

Credit: Caleb Blake | Photo Editor

Median sales prices of Columbus homes over the past five years, according to data from the Columbus Realtors Association.

Credit: Molly Goheen | Managing Editor for Digital Content
According to a 2023 study on Columbus housing by McKinsey, Columbus’ population increased by one-third from 2000 to 2021, making Columbus the fastest-growing city in the Midwest with 500,000 new residents. In 2022, the same report declared Columbus and its surrounding suburbs the fifth “hottest” housing market in the U.S.

This fast-growing housing market poses risks for lower-income residents and historically disadvantaged communities, who, according to Boos, have had issues with housing accessibility since the 1950s, which are being brought to light by the city’s recent development. 

“The foreclosure crisis because of all that had outsized impacts on households of color and female-headed households,” Boos said. “And even now, today, we are still working with zoning codes that were written in the 1950s that just don’t match what our morality is anymore. And you have implicit bias affecting the housing world in ways that isn’t always obvious until you start looking for it.

Columbus is currently in the process of rewriting zoning codes that haven’t been updated for over 70 years with proposals expected to be made this year. 

Although communities most at risk are people of color and single women, as Boos said, everyone is at risk.

Rent has gone up significantly in Columbus over the last 10 years, according to a 2022 study by the Ohio Housing Finance Agency. Between 2012 and 2022, the median rent has increased by 10% when adjusted for inflation, which is the highest on record. 

For homeowners, median sales prices have risen 22.6% from January to June 2023, from $262,750 to $322,205, according to Columbus Realtors’ June 2023 Central Ohio Housing Report

The average home in Ohio is valued at $213,149 according to Zillow. This means Central Ohio homes are over 1.5 times more expensive than the state average. 

Zillow also has a median rent in Columbus valued at $1,430, and the median for all Ohio rentals at $1,250. This number has gone up significantly from the U.S. Census Bureau’s 2018-2022 median gross rent calculation for Columbus of $1,161. Columbus is currently the most expensive major city to buy or rent, and prices are only projected to increase.

Median rental prices in Columbus for all types of housing over the past year, according to Zillow.

Credit: Molly Goheen | Managing Editor for Digital Content

Impact on Ohio State

As Reece said, Columbus will need to increase construction of new homes and the university will need to expand student housing opportunities. Despite that, he remains optimistic about current development. 

“We’ve had a long history of students kind of overpaying for lower quality housing, particularly in the University District,” Reece said. “It’s hard to anticipate the growth that we’re going to see, will that still persist? Will other investors come in and try to buy up properties? And also, I think we will benefit to a degree by the expansion of residential options on campus that we’ve seen built in the last decade.”

Amy Riegel, the executive director of the Coalition on Homelessness and Housing in Ohio, said students are a population that is at higher risk when it comes to finding affordable housing because of high demand and typically lower tenant protections. 

“I think that it is just another factor that makes college less affordable and harder to achieve for so many people within our communities,” Riegel said. “And it also adds risk levels to student housing that may create unsafe circumstances based upon overcrowding, or people rooming in areas of a home that just aren’t fit for a person to be staying in.”

Riegel said students graduating from Ohio State and other universities may struggle to find affordable housing even with a high-paying job that Intel could provide. 

“I talk to individuals on a regular basis, who are younger, who are coming out of their higher education. They have great jobs, like really good stable jobs, and they can barely afford an apartment, let alone really being able to put into perspective owning a home,” Riegel said. “And so we see that housing in central Columbus, or Central Ohio, is becoming more and more expensive and harder to find.”

Riegel, who lives in a college neighborhood in Dayton, said after a certain point, it becomes less profitable for landlords to rent to college students and more advantageous to rent to high-earning adults and families who want the benefits of being near a college campus like Ohio State. 

“If you get to the point, which I think Columbus’ numbers are probably approaching that region, or level, where a landlord renting to an everyday nonstudent would actually receive more rent continuously than renting to a student,” Riegel said. “And when you see those economics flip, it means that universities are kind of caught off guard because it takes universities a long time to build housing and to address adjustments in the market. And so it could leave students having to live further from campus, students to overcrowd in two units and students to pay way more.”

Despite this possibility, Riegel said she has been impressed by Ohio State’s construction efforts, such as building dorms and university housing upwards and condensing the university through higher-density housing instead of sprawling into other areas.

A rock and a hard place

Although the rapid development of Columbus threatens lower-income communities, proponents of these companies say Intel and others are not responsible for Columbus’ historical lack of housing. 

Still, McDonald said Intel and Columbus have to be mindful of the impact their arrival may have on the community. 

“I think anytime you have growth, especially really big stuff like this, there’s potential for it to be negative,” McDonald said. “But I would think that it’s one of the focus areas of the Columbus Partnership and One Columbus and all the communities that we work with on a daily basis, to mitigate those things. So as we grow, to build more housing, to make sure that we’re remaining to be an affordable place, that we’re building transit systems around in different ways, and we have great partnerships.”

The opportunities and economic growth expected to arrive in Columbus within the next 10 years could also offset the growing costs of the region, according to McDonald.

“I think these companies are an example of not only how we’re bringing new industries here, but their outreach to students and educators across our region, in particular minority populations, has been extraordinary by historical measure, and I have really high hopes that it will not only create jobs but create access for everybody to those jobs,” McDonald said.

Housing units in Columbus over the past five years have decreased in availability, according to the Columbus Realtors Association.

Credit: Molly Goheen | Managing Editor for Digital Content

In a housing crisis, at-risk communities include students, people of color, women and low-income individuals.

Credit: Caleb Blake | Photo Editor
Sherrice Thomas, the vice president of diversity, equity, inclusion and access for the Columbus Chamber of Commerce, serves on the Community Shelter Board and sees both the positive and negative components of Columbus’ expansion.

Thomas said the arrival of higher-income individuals to Columbus is inevitable, which will increase gentrification and housing prices. 

“They have the ability to pay certain prices for housing that others may not. And so as a result of that, it’s gonna drive up our housing prices,” Thomas said. “And I believe we see some of that happening now. But I want to be clear that it’s an unintentional consequence because we need that business to grow in order to thrive as a region.”

“They have the ability to pay certain prices for housing that others may not. And so as a result of that, it’s gonna drive up our housing prices,” Thomas said. “And I believe we see some of that happening now. But I want to be clear that it’s an unintentional consequence because we need that business to grow in order to thrive as a region.”

                                 — Sherrice Thomas, vice president of diversity, equity, inclusion and access for the Columbus Chamber of Commerce

According to Thomas, neighborhoods of color and regions such as Olde Towne East, are becoming increasingly gentrified and expensive, although this results in neighborhood amenities such as new apartments and businesses. 

“What we’re starting to see is those areas are being the word that many might use as gentrified,” Thomas said. “And as you can imagine, as the property value goes up, because different types of people move in, they begin to do different types of improvements on the homes and all of those things. When those property values go up, sometimes people who were in the neighborhood originally are priced out of their market. And so usually, that’s through income tax increases. And that becomes a little challenging [for] them.”

Solutions and implementation for development

In spite of the issues development brings, Thomas said leaders in Columbus are making an effort to address them on the government and nonprofit levels, as well as within private corporations. Updating zoning codes is a major step in the right direction for housing development. The Columbus Housing Strategy, implemented by Columbus Mayor Andrew Ginther, aims to double the supply of housing in the region and since 2019, over $250 million has been authorized for housing bond packages and other affordable housing initiatives. 

“Our city leaders knew this was going to be a challenge from the beginning,” Thomas said. “And it’s almost like they understand that we have to perform while we’re transforming. So they’re doing really great work.”

Rapid development requires conscious work on the side of all counterparts involved, including businesses, government and non-profits.

Credit: Molly Goheen | Managing Editor for Digital Content
Organizations like the Coalition on Homelessness & Housing in Ohio and the Affordable Housing Alliance of Central Ohio are doing some of the grassroots work to solve the housing crisis in Ohio and Columbus. COHHIO tracks and manages data on housing and homelessness in a variety of Ohio communities and offers educational programs for at-risk communities to break down barriers to accessible housing. AHACO has provided housing aid in the form of hundreds of millions of dollars and also provides resources for those looking for affordable housing. 

Boos said the housing crisis needs to be solved if Columbus wants to retain its reputation as a welcoming and affordable Midwestern city.

“It’s Midwestern to be able to buy a home when you’re 28,” Boos said. “And to build wealth and to raise a family and to have the security to maybe start a small business. When you start seeing single-family starter homes selling for $400,000-$500,000, that Midwestern identity is going to evaporate really quickly. And that doesn’t matter if you’re in Hilliard, or Reynoldsburg, or Upper Arlington or Granville, it’s going to be everywhere unless we act as a region to get ahead of it.”

Riegel mentioned the diversity of Ohio is part of what makes it such an appealing state. With rural, suburban and urban areas, Ohio and Columbus appeal to a wide variety of people but need the reputation of affordability to remain so.

“When you start seeing single-family starter homes selling for $400,000-$500,000, that Midwestern identity is going to evaporate really quickly. And that doesn’t matter if you’re in Hilliard, or Reynoldsburg, or Upper Arlington or Granville, it’s going to be everywhere unless we act as a region to get ahead of it.

                                                   — Carlie Boos, executive director at the Affordable Housing Alliance of Central Ohio

To help solve the housing crisis, Columbus needs to come together, recognize its diversity and realize it is a community issue, Boos said.

“I think we need to understand that even if I’m housing secure, I am actively losing out because other people don’t have enough housing,” Boos said. “So yes, get in the game, do the thing. fight for what’s right, because you believe it’s right. But also, we need to understand that we will all grow, we will all get stronger, and we will all directly benefit if we can solve this thing.”

Words by Phoebe Helms

Web Design by Gaurav Law